In light of my previous post on the benefits of government spending, you might wonder why I claim that reducing taxes is the better option in an even earlier post.
The problem is that both are necessary for a healthy economy. Government spending is beneficial to the economy, but low tax rates are also beneficial. The problem is that one requires the opposite of other (though you can delay the taxation by increasing debt). So if you increase government spending (good), you have to increase taxes (bad) or if you decrease taxes (good) you have to decrease spending (bad). Either extreme is bad so it isn't a question of which is better for the economy, the question is what is the correct balance point.
In both cases the benefit is diminishing as you increase the levels. Increased spending when spending is very low has a much higher benefit than it does when spending is high. The same is true for taxes, the lower the rate the less benefit you have from lowering it further.
For me it is less a question of which is better and more of a question of where the balance point is. There have been times when using spending would offer benefit despite the necessary raise in taxes and others where the reverse is true.
As for where we are at in the US today, I don't believe that increased spending is going to have an overall positive effect. The outstanding debt is far to high and is rising far too quickly in an unsustainable way, which means taxes will have to increase to cover the cost. The concern on what that increase will be, who it will affect, and when it will happen is having a hugely detrimental effect on the economy already. While there are many positive aspects to the spending programs which have been put in place in the past year, they also come with that significant negative.
That negative is compounded by the uncertainty of how the deficit will be handled, especially in light of how much debt the US has and how quickly it has risen. The ability of the US government to continue spending on credit has a limit and there are signs that limit is approaching. Further spending is going to exacerbate the problem even as it provides the benefits I have mentioned.
If the US had limited or no debt, then spending might be a good answer, though it does come with some risk. With spending levels already high and debt levels very high, I believe that the overall effect of increased spending not only doesn't help the economy, but I believe there is overall harm being done.
Sunday, September 12, 2010
How do you Stimulate an Economy? Part 3 - How Government Spending is Good for the Ecomony
So far with only me posting things have been a bit one sided. I do, however, have points that I can make on both sides of most issues. While I believe that economic stimulation from the government should mostly be based on reducing taxes (which I detail here), there are many benefits to using spending as a stimulus.
Government spending allows for development in areas which are either not directly profitable, or which will show profit only after too long of a term to make it a palatable investment for the private sector. Just because the initial venture isn't profitable, however, doesn't mean that there isn't substantial economic gain to be made, sometimes that venture will lead to others which turn a profit.
A clear example of this from the past is the space program. In the 1960s and 1970s building craft and systems capable of exploring the solar system, launching satellites, and putting people on the moon were not economically viable programs. While today that has changed, much of what has enable private industry to begin looking to outer space is a direct result from what NASA has already done. Indirectly there were advances in technology made to overcome the challenges of NASA's missions which where helpful for hundreds of other industries (NASA calls them spinoffs and has over 1600 of them in a database they also have a flash driven summary). In any case, there have been thousands of products which would have been either impossible to make, much more expensive, or vastly inferior had it not been for the space program. The space program significantly contributed to the economic growth which resulted from these products being developed cheaper, faster and better.
A current example that most people support is energy research. Alternative energy sources are mostly not economically viable for the private sector because they require too high of investments in the development of new technologies to make them either feasible or economically competitive with existing energy generation methods. If the initial investment is not made by government spending then the growth of these industries will be very slow. Government funding into this area, however, could result in a huge boost to the economy as new technologies are created to solve problems of energy creation. Even if none of the primary objectives are successful there are bound to be both short and long term benefits through technological advance and short term job creation.
Since government spending is not used to create direct profit, it can be used on areas which do not create a direct financial return on the investment, but also on programs which increase the quality of life, and therefore the wealth, of people. Examples of this are the creation of roads, power grids, and other infrastructure type projects. While there is little direct return expected from these ventures, and therefore little incentive for the private sector to get involved, these projects also allow for economic development. Increasing roadways allows for reduced transport times and therefore costs which not only helps business with delivering goods, but also people by reducing their travel costs. Less time commuting, shopping, driving kids, etc. results in more time for people to use to enrich their lives.
Finally, the government is run by people who can be held directly accountable to the people. Politicians have to act in the interests of most people or risk the loss of their position.
So government spending is necessary to a healthy economy. It drives stagnant industries forward when long term investment is required and creates short term boosts to the job market by creating a demand for products and services to overcome challenges which the private market is not yet willing to take on. It also allows for more indirect wealth creation since it is not limited to direct profitability. For all these reasons, we need to have a healthy amount of government spending to strengthen the economy.
Government spending allows for development in areas which are either not directly profitable, or which will show profit only after too long of a term to make it a palatable investment for the private sector. Just because the initial venture isn't profitable, however, doesn't mean that there isn't substantial economic gain to be made, sometimes that venture will lead to others which turn a profit.
A clear example of this from the past is the space program. In the 1960s and 1970s building craft and systems capable of exploring the solar system, launching satellites, and putting people on the moon were not economically viable programs. While today that has changed, much of what has enable private industry to begin looking to outer space is a direct result from what NASA has already done. Indirectly there were advances in technology made to overcome the challenges of NASA's missions which where helpful for hundreds of other industries (NASA calls them spinoffs and has over 1600 of them in a database they also have a flash driven summary). In any case, there have been thousands of products which would have been either impossible to make, much more expensive, or vastly inferior had it not been for the space program. The space program significantly contributed to the economic growth which resulted from these products being developed cheaper, faster and better.
A current example that most people support is energy research. Alternative energy sources are mostly not economically viable for the private sector because they require too high of investments in the development of new technologies to make them either feasible or economically competitive with existing energy generation methods. If the initial investment is not made by government spending then the growth of these industries will be very slow. Government funding into this area, however, could result in a huge boost to the economy as new technologies are created to solve problems of energy creation. Even if none of the primary objectives are successful there are bound to be both short and long term benefits through technological advance and short term job creation.
Since government spending is not used to create direct profit, it can be used on areas which do not create a direct financial return on the investment, but also on programs which increase the quality of life, and therefore the wealth, of people. Examples of this are the creation of roads, power grids, and other infrastructure type projects. While there is little direct return expected from these ventures, and therefore little incentive for the private sector to get involved, these projects also allow for economic development. Increasing roadways allows for reduced transport times and therefore costs which not only helps business with delivering goods, but also people by reducing their travel costs. Less time commuting, shopping, driving kids, etc. results in more time for people to use to enrich their lives.
Finally, the government is run by people who can be held directly accountable to the people. Politicians have to act in the interests of most people or risk the loss of their position.
So government spending is necessary to a healthy economy. It drives stagnant industries forward when long term investment is required and creates short term boosts to the job market by creating a demand for products and services to overcome challenges which the private market is not yet willing to take on. It also allows for more indirect wealth creation since it is not limited to direct profitability. For all these reasons, we need to have a healthy amount of government spending to strengthen the economy.
Friday, September 10, 2010
Why you can't increase taxes only on the rich.
It is common for politicians, when talking of raising taxes to promote the idea that they will be either taxing only the rich or taxing the rich more heavily. The idea being that they can raise the necessary revues by passing the costs only on those who can afford it.
Is that a something that any part or whole of the US government can do? I don't think so.
Certainly, they can raise the tax rates on only those with incomes in a certain range, or they can tax only goods and or services that only the wealthy are likely to use. But does that cost truly come from the wealthy? Again, the answer usually is no.
The problem is that, as I say with nearly everything, it is more complicated. You cannot simply isolate one part of our economy. When you make a change to one aspect, there are naturally changes to other parts.
Let us start with income taxes. If you raise taxes on these high earners, what will be the result?
First you must look at what you have done. What you have effectively done is increased the disparity between the business cost and the personal reward for the highest income labor. To help that make sense, let's put some numbers in there. Say we are talking about a $300,000 salary.(For now lets ignore other taxes, fees and benefits, since their impact is roughly the same before and after an income tax change). With our current tax rate, the employee would pay about 33% of that income in federal income tax. This means that it costs the company $300,000 to provide that employee with $201,000 in compensation (again excluding other taxes and benefits). If you were to increase the tax rate to 40% it would then cost the company $335,000 to provide the same $201,000 in compensation or alternatively the company can pay the same $300,000 and the employee with now earn only $180,000.
If the latter result above is what happens, then the tax would primarily affect the rich. Why is that considered to be even a likely outcome, much less the expected one? If you were to suddenly have a permanent pay decrease for performing the same job, how would you react? Would nothing change? People who earn high incomes are able to do so, because they have skills which are in high demand, they have a willingness to work at a higher level than most, and/or they are willing and able to take a much higher level of responsibility. If you decrease their compensation, most people are either going to move on to a place where they are better compensated or they are going to work less. Either way, what you have actually taxed is not the wealthy employee, but the business. It will have to either increase salaries to compensate to the taxes, or it will have to hire more people to do the additional work. Essentially, employees pass on the much cost of their taxes on to their employers. Though we negotiate gross salaries, it is the net salaries that really concern employees. Someone isn't going to do the same work for $7 an hour in take home pay that they will do for $9 an hour, even if the gross pay is $12 in either case. The same is true (perhaps more so) for those earning much higher wages.
Fair enough, businesses that can afford to pay people enough to be wealthy are wealth themselves, so taxing them is till taxing the rich. Not exactly.
The problem with taxing companies is that you are simply increase their labor costs. When a company has increased costs they can do many things, but they all boil down into one of two actions. Either they increase the price of their product or they lower its quality. This means that the increased costs of the company are felt, not by the employees but by their customers.
This is the same scenario you run into if you increase corporate or business taxes. Increasing those taxes is simply increasing the cost of the goods or services that the business provides. The reaction of the business will be to pass on that cost to the consumers. In some cases this can force a reduction in the size of the company, which can cause layoffs. The reason for this is probably a topic for another post, but it happens is most cases.
This leaves only investment income as a source of taxing the rich. Here again, you run largely into the same problem. If you increase taxes on investment gains then you simply reduce the return on those investments. This forces those seeking investment funds to offer more to get the same investment. Just because investments are more expensive doesn't mean that investors are willing to risk their funds for a lower return. The result of this is that starting companies are not able to retain as much revenue to use for growth and expansion as they instead have to use more to repay investors. It also means that potentially profitable business are not able to get funding as their potential profits are not hight enough to attract investors.
None of what I have outlined above is 100%. In reality the wealthy individuals targeted will pay some of the tax increases, but they will pay nowhere near all of them and the rest will be paid, indirectly, by the non-wealthy. So while you can increase taxes on the rich and you can increase how much they pay, you cannot do so without a significant portion of those tax increases actually being paid by the poor and the middle class.
Is that a something that any part or whole of the US government can do? I don't think so.
Certainly, they can raise the tax rates on only those with incomes in a certain range, or they can tax only goods and or services that only the wealthy are likely to use. But does that cost truly come from the wealthy? Again, the answer usually is no.
The problem is that, as I say with nearly everything, it is more complicated. You cannot simply isolate one part of our economy. When you make a change to one aspect, there are naturally changes to other parts.
Let us start with income taxes. If you raise taxes on these high earners, what will be the result?
First you must look at what you have done. What you have effectively done is increased the disparity between the business cost and the personal reward for the highest income labor. To help that make sense, let's put some numbers in there. Say we are talking about a $300,000 salary.(For now lets ignore other taxes, fees and benefits, since their impact is roughly the same before and after an income tax change). With our current tax rate, the employee would pay about 33% of that income in federal income tax. This means that it costs the company $300,000 to provide that employee with $201,000 in compensation (again excluding other taxes and benefits). If you were to increase the tax rate to 40% it would then cost the company $335,000 to provide the same $201,000 in compensation or alternatively the company can pay the same $300,000 and the employee with now earn only $180,000.
If the latter result above is what happens, then the tax would primarily affect the rich. Why is that considered to be even a likely outcome, much less the expected one? If you were to suddenly have a permanent pay decrease for performing the same job, how would you react? Would nothing change? People who earn high incomes are able to do so, because they have skills which are in high demand, they have a willingness to work at a higher level than most, and/or they are willing and able to take a much higher level of responsibility. If you decrease their compensation, most people are either going to move on to a place where they are better compensated or they are going to work less. Either way, what you have actually taxed is not the wealthy employee, but the business. It will have to either increase salaries to compensate to the taxes, or it will have to hire more people to do the additional work. Essentially, employees pass on the much cost of their taxes on to their employers. Though we negotiate gross salaries, it is the net salaries that really concern employees. Someone isn't going to do the same work for $7 an hour in take home pay that they will do for $9 an hour, even if the gross pay is $12 in either case. The same is true (perhaps more so) for those earning much higher wages.
Fair enough, businesses that can afford to pay people enough to be wealthy are wealth themselves, so taxing them is till taxing the rich. Not exactly.
The problem with taxing companies is that you are simply increase their labor costs. When a company has increased costs they can do many things, but they all boil down into one of two actions. Either they increase the price of their product or they lower its quality. This means that the increased costs of the company are felt, not by the employees but by their customers.
This is the same scenario you run into if you increase corporate or business taxes. Increasing those taxes is simply increasing the cost of the goods or services that the business provides. The reaction of the business will be to pass on that cost to the consumers. In some cases this can force a reduction in the size of the company, which can cause layoffs. The reason for this is probably a topic for another post, but it happens is most cases.
This leaves only investment income as a source of taxing the rich. Here again, you run largely into the same problem. If you increase taxes on investment gains then you simply reduce the return on those investments. This forces those seeking investment funds to offer more to get the same investment. Just because investments are more expensive doesn't mean that investors are willing to risk their funds for a lower return. The result of this is that starting companies are not able to retain as much revenue to use for growth and expansion as they instead have to use more to repay investors. It also means that potentially profitable business are not able to get funding as their potential profits are not hight enough to attract investors.
None of what I have outlined above is 100%. In reality the wealthy individuals targeted will pay some of the tax increases, but they will pay nowhere near all of them and the rest will be paid, indirectly, by the non-wealthy. So while you can increase taxes on the rich and you can increase how much they pay, you cannot do so without a significant portion of those tax increases actually being paid by the poor and the middle class.
Friday, September 3, 2010
The Increasing Income Gap Between the Rich and the Poor
It is often cited with concern that the gap between the rich and the poor is widening. Usually this comes as a preface to some plan on how to either limit the income of the rich or to increase the income of the poor. Basically this gap is seen by many as a problem which needs to be addresses.
Is this gap really growing? The answer, of course, is yes....and no. Like most things with statistics, it depends on what you are really measuring. If you are looking at dollars of income then, of course, this gap is growing. Is that, however the meaningful measure? I would say that it is not. Rather, the meaningful statistic that should be considered for this type of analysis is quality of life. It is less often used, because it is much harder to define and since dollar income is a strong indicator for quality of life that is much easier.
The problem with looking only at dollar income is that, the dollar's contribution to quality of life is not linear it is a diminishing curve. What I mean by that is that for someone who makes $20,000 a year giving them an extra $1,000 has far greater impact to their quality of life than giving someone who makes $1 million an extra $1,000. (I would say that the curve is sharper than even an inverse geometric curve or that giving someone who makes $1 million and extra $50,000 would also be less impacting than giving the $20,000 earner an extra $1,000, but that is both debatable and not as much to the point).
The problem is that, especially as the high end of spending, there is a very diminishing return for spending. Take cars, for example. You can buy a nice, reliable, new car for under $20,000. On the other end of the spectrum you can pay easily over $400,000 for something like a Ferrari 599 (that's not even including the exotics like the Bugati Veyron which costs over $1.4 million, though I'm also ignoring that you can get a very reliably quality used care for under $10,000). So yes, a wealthy person can easily spend 20 times as much to get a new car. Does that translate into a twenty-fold increase in quality of life? Not even close. Don't get me wrong, Ferrari's a beautiful cars and I would love to drive one personally, but it doesn't hold near that value to me or, I would argue, to very many.
Perhaps cars are not a fair comparison. What about food? Meals at the top-end, first class restaurants can average over $175 per person and that's not including wine which can drive it up to $300 per person (again, that's not including the extreme cases such as the $30,000 meal in this article. or having a $2 per person low-end home cooked meal) On the other end of the scale you can get a meal at a low end restaurant (such as fast food) for under $7. Certainly, the top end meal is far better, and as a one time thing, it might even be the 25 times better that it costs. But we aren't talking about one time, we are comparing what wealth can buy. For that we are talking about normal living. Even if we talk about looking at the cost difference only of dinner now you are talking about a difference of $1,176 a week or over $60,000 a year. If you include high end wines you can double that easily. Now, if I make over a $1 million a year, then spending over $60,000 on food doesn't seem crazy, as percent of income it is the same as the person making $20,000 spending $1,800 on food for the year. Still, does increasing the quality from the type of meal you can get for $7 to the type of meal you can get for $175 really count as 25 times better? Again, don't think so. If you aren't convinced then look at the middle ground. An $80 per person meal is amazingly better than a $7, if not nearly 12 times as good, it might be close. However do you think that the $175 meal is over twice as good as the $80? Better, yes, but that much better?
You can look at nearly any area of quality of life measure and find the same thing. While the rich have many more dollars, as you spend more and more money on things you get rapidly diminishing increases to the quality of life for each dollar spent. At the same time, I would say that the difference between the middle top and the middle bottom end of quality of life items available is shrinking. Even low income families have access to entertainment options which rival those of the wealthy. Sure you might have to watch the Super Bowl at home on a mid-size TV as part of your $50 a month cable bill and have it catered by Subway for about $6 per person instead of a $15,000 luxury game suite, but you are still watching the same game. Yes the rich live better, even far better than the poor. But the relationship is certainly not accurately portrayed by just looking at the dollars of income.
Is this gap really growing? The answer, of course, is yes....and no. Like most things with statistics, it depends on what you are really measuring. If you are looking at dollars of income then, of course, this gap is growing. Is that, however the meaningful measure? I would say that it is not. Rather, the meaningful statistic that should be considered for this type of analysis is quality of life. It is less often used, because it is much harder to define and since dollar income is a strong indicator for quality of life that is much easier.
The problem with looking only at dollar income is that, the dollar's contribution to quality of life is not linear it is a diminishing curve. What I mean by that is that for someone who makes $20,000 a year giving them an extra $1,000 has far greater impact to their quality of life than giving someone who makes $1 million an extra $1,000. (I would say that the curve is sharper than even an inverse geometric curve or that giving someone who makes $1 million and extra $50,000 would also be less impacting than giving the $20,000 earner an extra $1,000, but that is both debatable and not as much to the point).
The problem is that, especially as the high end of spending, there is a very diminishing return for spending. Take cars, for example. You can buy a nice, reliable, new car for under $20,000. On the other end of the spectrum you can pay easily over $400,000 for something like a Ferrari 599 (that's not even including the exotics like the Bugati Veyron which costs over $1.4 million, though I'm also ignoring that you can get a very reliably quality used care for under $10,000). So yes, a wealthy person can easily spend 20 times as much to get a new car. Does that translate into a twenty-fold increase in quality of life? Not even close. Don't get me wrong, Ferrari's a beautiful cars and I would love to drive one personally, but it doesn't hold near that value to me or, I would argue, to very many.
Perhaps cars are not a fair comparison. What about food? Meals at the top-end, first class restaurants can average over $175 per person and that's not including wine which can drive it up to $300 per person (again, that's not including the extreme cases such as the $30,000 meal in this article. or having a $2 per person low-end home cooked meal) On the other end of the scale you can get a meal at a low end restaurant (such as fast food) for under $7. Certainly, the top end meal is far better, and as a one time thing, it might even be the 25 times better that it costs. But we aren't talking about one time, we are comparing what wealth can buy. For that we are talking about normal living. Even if we talk about looking at the cost difference only of dinner now you are talking about a difference of $1,176 a week or over $60,000 a year. If you include high end wines you can double that easily. Now, if I make over a $1 million a year, then spending over $60,000 on food doesn't seem crazy, as percent of income it is the same as the person making $20,000 spending $1,800 on food for the year. Still, does increasing the quality from the type of meal you can get for $7 to the type of meal you can get for $175 really count as 25 times better? Again, don't think so. If you aren't convinced then look at the middle ground. An $80 per person meal is amazingly better than a $7, if not nearly 12 times as good, it might be close. However do you think that the $175 meal is over twice as good as the $80? Better, yes, but that much better?
You can look at nearly any area of quality of life measure and find the same thing. While the rich have many more dollars, as you spend more and more money on things you get rapidly diminishing increases to the quality of life for each dollar spent. At the same time, I would say that the difference between the middle top and the middle bottom end of quality of life items available is shrinking. Even low income families have access to entertainment options which rival those of the wealthy. Sure you might have to watch the Super Bowl at home on a mid-size TV as part of your $50 a month cable bill and have it catered by Subway for about $6 per person instead of a $15,000 luxury game suite, but you are still watching the same game. Yes the rich live better, even far better than the poor. But the relationship is certainly not accurately portrayed by just looking at the dollars of income.
Thursday, September 2, 2010
Why Disease Might be a Good Thing.
Just to show this isn't all going to be about the economy, I thought I would start with one of my notions that probably seems very strange on the surface. I believe that disease is a good thing.
Now before you leave thinking that I am a lunatic, I certainly don't think it is good for the individual. I don't wish disease or illness on anyone and I certainly strive to avoid getting sick myself. That is not what I mean. I am talking more in the context of for humanity as a whole. This is still an odd premise, I will grant you, but if you bear with me, I believe it will make sense.
Let us start with another question: What prevents the populations of any species from continual exponential growth? I can think of only four things: predation, limited food, disease, and limited reproduction. In a world of limited resources, any species will multiply to a point where it's population growth is greatly slowed or halted by all four of them to a greater or lesser degree.
For most species on our planet predation is at the top of the list. Many species are limited by being either a food source or an inferior competitor to other species. This is what keeps rabbits and mice from completely taking over the planet. As a limit to population growth this is certainly effective, but it is also brutal and unpleasant. As humans we have few predators, since our intelligence, community and mastery of technology has allowed us to become superior (at least in terms of killing power and in the general sense) to all other species on the planet. If that were not the case, human existence would be much worse off. Imagine a world where there were superior predators who kept our population growth limited. Much of our lives would be devoted to survival and those who were slower, weaker, or otherwise less likely to survive would live in greater fear and horror. Or worse, and probably more likely, people would begin to control the system, by finding ways to sabotage either other into becoming the next victims. Humans are much better off to suffer very limited predation from another species.
Humans have through history feared predation from other humans as differing civilizations have clashed over resources or ideology. These wars have limited populations growth for humans on occasion, but thankfully warfare has not often been a primary limitation to the growth of human population. If there were not for the other limits on population growth, however, a world of constant warfare over limited resources would certainly be a very likely possibility.
Limited food is probably the largest growth limiter for early stage civilizations of humankind. While it extreme cases it lead to starvation, it often limited growth less harshly by reducing life expectancy and reproduction through both malnutrition and highly demanding lifestyles (often leading to very high infant and child mortality rates). As humans began to form civilizations, however, limited resources turned instead into warfare. Fortunately, civilization came largely because of increases in human ability to gather food allowing us to avoid (for the most part) the horrors of massive warfare for resources needed to survive. With that increase in available resources, however, human populations were able to expand rapidly. This would have lead quickly to just that type of warfare but for two things: expansion and disease.
Human expansion could delay the problem, but it was always limited by human ability to either get to or successfully live in new lands. Eventually, without another limiter humans would grow in population to fill all the usable land area. As technology increased, so does the usable land, but that would eventually have limits, and often times in our history, expansion could not occur fast enough to allow enough resources for the growing populations.
That brings us to disease. Don't get me wrong, disease is terrible. When you compare it to the alternatives, however, it doesn't look so bad. Disease limited massive populations from rising in small areas. If it weren't for disease, there would have instead been a mix of wide spread starvation and warfare(human predation) which would have limited populations in localized areas through history. It was disease which kept either of those things from happening.
Now you might argue that death is death, and that dying from disease is no better than being killed in war or starving. Looking at the individual, I would agree. Looking at the bigger picture, however, I do not. What makes disease preferable is that is semi-random, but that there are many things which can be done to reduce the odds, and these actions lead to less damaging moral decisions because it is largely out of human control. Starvation can be controlled by human decision and action to the point that it would lead to warfare followed by subjugation of the losing population (likely defined by ethnicity, culture, religion, or other generic trait). The subjugated population would suffer from starvation unless they were able to grow in power and overthrow the oppressing population at which time the roles would change and the cycle would likely repeat until something happened to either vastly decrease the population or vastly increase the available food. This would not only lead to terrible life for one people group or another, but leads greatly to the moral corruption as people would constantly be faced with deciding who gets to live and who has to die.
Disease, however, has been mostly out of control of humans for most of history. As I said earlier it affects individuals in a semi-random manner (at least to the perceptions of humans for most of history), there were things which could be done to limit risk, but not eliminate it. You couldn't control it to the point of directing it at any population group and you could not eliminate it to the point that it didn't reduce human population. It is the one population control that would not lead early civilizations to ruin.
I saved limited reproduction for last, because in the past hundred years or so, things have changed greatly. Technology has both greatly limited the impact of disease while at the same time allowing for far more limited reproduction. Limited reproduction is certainly the most desirable limit to population growth as it does not involve death. If it is present in a species too early, however, there is the large risk that the species will not expand, but rather become extinct. If humans took far longer to reproduce, it is unlikely that we would have survived. Certainly many civilizations would have been lost after major outbreaks of war, famine, or other large scale population reduction. Humans might never have had the localized numbers to cooperate and develop technologies which allowed them to overcome other species or expand their food supply to overcome starvation. Today, since we have already accomplished these things and have a large, widespread population, limited reproduction is the desirable course. In fact, we limited our population greatly, and some fear that in the cases of some nations, too much. Humanity, however, will survive especially since we are better mastering both birth control and limiting disease at the same time.
While the need for disease is largely passing, I believe it has been very beneficial to our past. I have not been able to come up with an alternative which would lead to a better outcome for us. Perhaps one of you will. I, however, believe that without disease the world would certainly be a different place, and I suspect that place would be much worse than the world we have today.
Wednesday, September 1, 2010
How do you Stimulate an Economy? Part 2 - Why Aaron prefers Tax Cuts
In part 1 I discussed how difficult it is to even know what is the correct course of action to take to help improve an economy. The is both a remarkably complex system and one in which seemingly small events can have massive impact. Mathematically speaking it is a chaotic system, which makes it very hard to predict much less guide and control.
That is the primary reason that I prefer using tax cuts to stimulate the economy. While I don't think businesses are inherently any more competent or less corrupt than politicians, the bottom line is that there are many more of them and their methods produce success or failure much more directly for them and much more quickly. This leads to a system in which many different plans are attempted and ones which lead to success are emulated and refined while ones that lead to failure are discarded.
Now of course, on major drawback is that these plans are not designed for the benefit of the economy, but rather for the benefit of the company, or the company owner/shareholder. Such actions, however, almost always also increase the overall economy. Making businesses successful is the key driver in making the economy healthy.
The plan of using the government spending, provides more direct control of things into the hands of fewer decision makers. That can be a good thing, especially when there is a clear case of something that needs to be done. A good example of this, and something good that is in the current US stimulus is funding research into non-hydrocarbon energy generation. While I have some disagreements with the details of how it is being done, overall it is a good program to use government funding to promote this research. However, that is because even if it isn't something that will directly help the economy overall in the near term (it in help in many ways and hurt in many others) it is something that, if successful, will help the economy greatly in the long term by reducing the costs (either political or economic) of energy. Because it is clearly beneficial to the economy and may be too long term to be correctly promoted by business it is a good candidate for government funding. However, those cases are, I believe, limited in number.
It is far more often that we don't know what the best path to promoting the economy is and when that is the case I prefer, to steal the term from Glenn Reynolds, an Army of Davids to the management of a Goliath. As we decrease tax burdens it increases profitability and therefore incentive for new players to enter with new ideas. Yes, we also get old players with old ideas, but failing ideas lead to either abandonment or failing business, successful ideas lead to emulation.
So while I think that both spending and tax reduction can and to stimulate the economy in some ways and depress it in others, overall I prefer tax reduction because it empowers larger numbers of solutions to a problem that we don't understand well enough to have all the answers for.
Tuesday, August 31, 2010
How do you Stimulate an Economy? Part 1
How do you stimulate an economy? Sadly this is a question that few people seem to ask, rather they are intent on experimenting with their chosen answer. In the US we have the Democrats who largely support using government funding to stimulate economic growth, and the Republicans who largely support lowering taxes to do the same.
The problem we face is that there isn't a clear answer. Which answer works? Answering that is similar to asking if a volcanic eruption in Africa will affect the weather in Asia. The answer...we don't really know. Like the weather the economy is a very complex system and while we are fairly good at prediction both in short time periods, it is far more difficult to point to specific actions and accurately predict their results. It is sadly, also very difficult to look back into the past and knowing the result point to what was the primary cause. There are simply too many factors which have too many effects for us to track.
In theory we should be able to look at a hurricane and trace all of the weather patterns back to determine what were the primary causes and use that information to accurately predict them in the future (or possibly to either create them or prevent their formation). In practice, there is too much information and we have to use computer models which necessarily simplify many factors based on our understanding of how important they are. This causes our models to be only somewhat accurate and reliable at even predicting what is going to happen, which makes it very difficult to point to how. The economy is much the same. There are several schools of thought because we cannot model the system accurately enough to determine even the causes of why things happened in the past. That, however, doesn't stop people from having beliefs and opinions.
That said, let's look at the two solutions above.
The idea behind a government spending stimulus is that the government can step in and provide demand for goods and/or services which will stimulate businesses to meet that demand. As businesses expand to meet the new demand, they stimulate the general economy as all business growth does (job creation, innovation, etc.) This temporary demand can either hold the economy steady through a recession or even eliminate the recession and restore healthy economic growth. Or at least, that is the theory. Does it really work? We don't know. And we don't know because there are other factors that come into play when you take such an action and those factors can also have a significant impact on the economy.
To look at just one of these factors, consider where the money spent on the stimulus comes from. Government spending on a significant enough scale to increase demand will also impact the economy in other ways. If the money is borrowed (as it has been with our current stimulus) it will reduce capital available to businesses, as the government is either borrowing more and competing with businesses for credit, or it is lending less and therefore not providing as many loans to businesses. To avoid reducing capital availability you could alternatively increase taxes, tariffs, or other sources of government revenue, but they all have drawbacks as well. Increasing taxes reduces profitability for businesses which can lead to either stagnant growth or price increases. Increasing tariffs can cause reprisal increases on US goods which would also lead to reduced revenues. Is this negative effect enough to overcome the positive effect of the stimulus. Probably not, but is only one factor. There are a host of other factors, both positive and negative and there are certainly many that I am not aware of. On the balance it is difficult to know if it will be successful or not.
The tax cut plan has similar difficulties. It is certainly true that by decreasing taxes you will provide more capital to business through private investors and you increase business revenues by reducing their tax burden. At the same time you are reducing government revenues which will decrease government created demand which affects overall demand and can cause a stagnating effect. You also increase consumer demand since a tax reduction provides more revenue to people. On the other hand, making any changes to the tax codes can cause a vast number of unintended consequences as you are altering a system that has been tailors over the years to promote or discourage various financial practices. As with the spending plan, the complexity grows over many factors very quickly.
Is it possible to add all of these factors up for each side and determine which course is better, or perhaps if there is a better course of action? Someday, perhaps. But right now, if it were possible to model the economy with that precision, we would not have the debates and arguments we currently have.
Yet, at the same time, how often are we just supporting the practice we prefer and justifying our belief by focusing on the positive indicators that do exits in our preferred plan? Increased government spending helps to promote and support many other things that Democrats want to support. It shifts power away from wealthy corporations and individuals and into a government which they can hold more directly accountable for their actions. Tax reductions, on the other hand, align more with the values of the Republican party, by pulling power away from government agencies and administrators who are often not directly affected by their decisions and actions.
Personally, I do believe more in the tax cut plan than I do in the stimulus, but only to a limited extent and not for any of the reasons outlined so far in this post. Part of my support probably comes from my desire for a smaller, less powerful government, but more of it has to do with what I believe is a better path to finding the optimal solution to a problem. That, however, is another post and one that I promise will appear soon.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)