Showing posts with label Politics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Politics. Show all posts

Monday, November 8, 2010

Where We Go From Here

In the recent election a strong message was set to the US Government.  That message was not that the Republicans should return to power or that the Democrats should be removed from power.  That message, I believe, was that Democrats and Republicans need to stop playing the same game that they have been playing with each other and with the public.  When it comes to fiscal policy, both parties agree that there should be a balanced budget, but for both parties it is a much lower priority than their other financial plans. 

Republicans want to decrease taxes or at the very least not raise them.   Democrats want to expand services or at the very least not cut them back.  Each party has been ever more willing, especially in recent years, to rack up large deficits rather than go against their preferences.  That is what has to stop.   We are no longer in a position to keep compromising by just building up debt.  Services need to be cut and taxes are going to have to increase.  For too long we have been compromising by increasing debt.  That policy needs to end.  What I, and I believe most voters want is for this country's leadership to show some fiscal responsibility for a change.   We didn't have that under the Bush administration and we don't have it under the Obama administration.  

Democrats have been arguing that their spending programs will help the economy recover.  They believe that without government spending things would be worse.  They might even be correct.  Experts wildly disagree on the subject.  What they don't disagree on, however, is that large scale deficit spending is very harmful.  Our current policies have been trading certain future wealth for a possible short term gain.  While the idea is to take from a plentiful future and help ease a troubled present, there are no assurances.  We don't know that we can afford to take from the future.  We don't know how much the spending will help the present.  Worst of all, we don't know when or how things will change.  How long can or will the spending go on?  How many of the jobs created by unsustainable spending will be temporary?  Will the economy recover in time to take up the slack for decreased spending or will this spending only postpone and possibly worsen a recession?  Many negative effects are likely or certain, but the positives appear to be highly speculative.

Many Republican plans are no better.  Cutting taxes might help the private sector to grow the economy, but it will certainly result in increasing deficits now which leads to all of the same negatives of the Democrats plans for all of the same reasons.   We don't have any more certainty that the positive effects of providing more money to the private sector will outweigh the costs than we do that direct spending will.  Either way we are betting probable short term positives against certain long term costs.   That is a poor investment.
Instead, we need to show fiscal restraint and responsibility.  Even a good investment is not a good investment if we cannot afford it.  There is always an element of risk and if you cannot afford to lose you should not play.  Some deficit spending is worth the risk, as you can often have investments which pay out higher than the cost of borrowing to invest.   Taking that too far, however, leads to disaster. 

Both parties have worked to bring us where we are today, which is with massive debt which is growing at an astonishing rate.  We have been living too far beyond our means for too long.  The unfortunate reality is that we have been gambling that we could continue to outgrow our current debt with future revenues for far too long.  We have lost sight of financial responsibility and have instead grown accustom to living outside our means.  We need to correct that, and it isn't going to be pleasant. 

For some time, I have been advocating that while compromise in politics is often a good thing, that it is also often very bad.  I have applauded the fact the Republicans refused to be bargained into most of the spending programs for the past couple of years.  As I saw it, the current administration was going down the same spending path as the previous one, only faster.  I felt it was the wrong direction and so I encouraged an end to compromise to stop the out of control spending.

In that, I have been wrong.  It had been bothering me for a bit, because I don't like the idea of not working in cooperation to make things better.  I like the idea of compromise in most situations where people disagree and yet I was seeing a lot of damage come from compromises made between the parties.  The problem is not compromise, the problem is the type of compromise.  Rather than compromise by each party pursuing its primary fiscal goals, we need to compromise first on pursuing the shared goal of limited deficit spending and reducing the debt.   Working within that shared goal we need to make sacrifices in our non-shared, but individually higher priorities.

Taxes need to be raised.  Spending has to be cut.  We need to shift away from the compromise of double spending and instead compromise on double cutting.  Our government cannot afford to offer all of the services we enjoy at the tax rate we have.   Increasing taxes will only get us so far, cutting services will eventually be far too harmful.  It is in this that we need to compromise with each other and work opposing each other in the details but together in the common goal of bringing this country back into a fiscally responsible path.
That is the message I believe the voters have sent in this recent election, and it is a message that I hope both parties come to hear.  We are willing to have fewer services if it means more financial responsibility.  We are willing to pay more taxes, if it also comes with more financial responsibility.  We are not willing to let the parties gamble with our futures with the costly and risky plans that they have been proposing and implementing so far.  There may be some short term pain, but it is largely a cost of letting things get so far out of hand for so long.

We can get this country back on track, and the answer isn't to follow the ideological path of either party, but rather to shift the give and take of compromise which cause us each to sacrifice a little for the sake of financial responsibility rather than each of us gain a little borrowing against our future.


Thursday, September 23, 2010

How to Help People - Part 2 Moral Help

It is perhaps somewhat ironic that Democrats and Republicans have completely reversed positions on the government providing moral assistance to people rather than financial.

When I talk of moral help, I am referring to programs designed to help people to be better people, as opposed to financially better off.  While there can be some overlap such as with education, but here I am referring to programs which deal with non-financial morality.  Examples of this would be anti-drug laws and programs or things like sex education.  Some public decency laws and the like would also fall into this category.

The moral issue is far more complicated than the financial one because there are several factors at play when it comes to morality.  Some moral issues are beneficial to society.  A clear example of this is a prohibition against murder.  Other moral issues have less clear benefit to society, such as a prohibition against abortion.  It is further complicated by the fact that society does not have a unified moral code, but rather has a large variety of moral codes which mostly overlap in a few major areas.  While many laws are based on some aspect of a moral code their intent is rarely focused on the individual, but rather on the protection of society as a whole.

So when looking to provide moral assistance to someone, then, there are two important questions to look at.  First, there is the question, as with financial help, of how much help is beneficial.  Second, there is the question of which moral code to use.

Let us begin with the first question and look at one of the larger examples of moral law in US history: Prohibition.  In 1920 the US nationally banned the sale, manufacture, transportation, and consumption of alcohol.    Those who supported prohibition did so for both individual and societal reasons.  Religious groups were split on the issue, but there were many who saw drinking as a sin and wanted the law to help prevent people from doing so. The vast majority, however, supported prohibition because they believed it would have six primary effects:  reduction of crime, protection of families(from effects of alcohol abusers), reduced drunkenness, reduces cases of insanity, reduced government cost (primarily through crime reduction), and a greater general respect for the law.  It was inarguable that alcohol had negative effects on all of those areas.  Alcohol was at the center of a great deal of lawless behavior and caused many societal problems.  What they didn't realize was that the problems created by banning alcohol were far worse.

The years of prohibition in the US showed that banning alcohol was not only worse for society overall, but it was worse in all six areas that it was intended to improve.  Though there were many positive effects to prohibition, they were greatly overshadowed by the negatives.  Overall alcohol consumption declined.  It was the moderate alcohol consumption which disappeared rather than the excessive drinking which was the source of problems.  Excessive drinking actually increased.  Crime actually increased due to the creation of a vast black market in alcohol and the violence between gangs which came with fighting for control of that market.  Government spending was greatly increased in an attempt to deal with the gangs.  Because of the clear ineffectiveness of the government to enforce the law, and the growing unpopularity of the law as it failed to have positive effects, respect for the law greatly decreased.  In the end the attempts to help improve society with a moral and very popular law proved to be harmful and lead to a less moral society.

That one case certainly doesn't invalidate all attempts to use government to help people morally, but it does show that there can be harmful unintended consequences to the attempts to do so.  Any law compelling moral behavior limits personal freedom, which means it comes with a high cost.  In many cases that cost is justified.  There is nearly universal support for laws against murder, assault, theft, fraud, and the like.  These are laws which agree with nearly everyone's moral code and which consequently have clearly seen benefits to society by most people.


In other cases it is less clear.  Take, for example, sex.  There are two aspects to government involvement in sex laws and sex education.  First there is an interest in protecting society.  There are problems with sexual predation or teens and children, unwanted pregnancies, and disease which almost all people agree are damaging to society.  Laws and programs designed to eliminate these problems are typically popular as long as they are not too extreme. 

Some people wish to take the issue further.  Most of the population believes that teenagers, especially those under 18 should not have sex.  There is a pretty wide range on how strongly people feel about the issue and many who agree that that teenage sex is a bad idea don't support any action taken to limit it.  Aside from laws which are designed to prevent adults from taking advantage of teenagers, there has not been much legal action to address the problem.  Instead the focus has mostly been on sex education and subsidized birth control and disease prevention.

It is here that there is a pretty strong divide.  On one side people argue that providing teenagers with condoms and other devices used to prevent disease and pregnancy will lead to an increase in teenage sexual activity.  This is probably true, however, the greatest increase will be in the more responsible sex and it will result in a decline of unprotected sex.  So you have both desirable and undesirable outcomes.  This is further complicated by the fact that birth control and disease prevention are not completely effective.  Even responsible sex leads to the outcomes society is attempting to prevent.

This goes to the other argument which is that sex should not be promoted among teenagers by supplying them with what they need to have sex more responsibly.  This is mostly supported more strongly by those who believe that teenage sex is always irresponsible.  They argue that there is an emotional toll on people who engage in sexual activity at an early age and that teenagers should be protected from making such harmful decisions.  This is much the same rational as is used for laws against alcohol and tobacco for teens and children.   

What we have is that overall teenage sex is leads to a number of problems.  There are many things which can be done to reduce the problems created, but these same actions will also result in an overall increase.  At the same time, strong discouragement can drive the more responsible to act less responsibly if they have limited access.  In many ways this is similar to the alcohol situation, though there are certainly some significant differences.  Still, you are faces with some of the same challenges.  Does reducing the overall activity result in greater or less harm than does increasing the activity and reducing the harm per incident?

The real problem is that there is great disagreement on how harmful different aspects are with the greatest disagreement on the amount of harm caused by any teenage sex, which is why you have such a difference of public opinion.  There are many who believe that responsible teenage sex is not a problem at all, so increasing total activity, if you decrease irresponsible activity is a good thing.  On the other side you have those who believe there is still great harm in responsible teenage sex, so increasing the total to increase responsibility is not a good thing.  Most people fall between the two positions believing that teenage sex is somewhat bad and that responsible teenage sex is less bad.

The result is that there is great disagreement on which path is better, which is largely why there has been little activity in attempting to pass laws in the area and instead the focus is on education and subsidizing programs.

My personal belief is that teenagers should not be having sex, I think that there is great harm to them in doing so.  Ultimately, however, it is their choice and while I agree that they are often not yet responsible enough to make that choice wisely, limiting their options is not a good idea.  I strongly support teaching that abstinence is the best way, but I also believe you should teach teenagers who choose to have sex how to do so more responsibly.   I realize that will probably lead to greater choices which I think are harmful, but it will also reduce the most harmful ones.  Finally, as much as I would like to protect young adults from making decisions which have such consequences, I don't want to use ignorance to do so.  The truth is that while they may not be prepared to make such decisions wisely, they are the ones who have to make the decision.  I believe we should do everything we can to help them make a better decision, even if that means fewer blindly choose to make the best one.

These are only two examples and moral issues are always complicated.  I am strongly in support of laws and programs which prevent harm to society, but I believe that should be the overriding concern. I recognize that, just as in the case of alcohol, sometimes the intent to reduce harm can lead to greater harm.  Where I disagree with many of my fellow Republicans is that my focus for the law is on damage mitigation rather than either doing what is right or in coercing others to do so.  While I believe their intent is good, the result would not always be.  

Sunday, September 19, 2010

How to Help People - Part 1 Financial Help

Most of the more divisive issues between the Republican and Democratic parties are among the array of domestic issues and most of those can fall into the definition of attempts to help people.  These break into two main areas: moral and economic.

Let's begin with the economic side.

When I talk about economically helping people, I am referring to any programs which provide goods or services to people either without charge or at a greatly reduced price.  All charity work is a form of economic assistance at some level.  There are different types of charity both private and public where the aid is giving in specific form such as offering food, education, child care, medical treatment, etc.  Other programs require some type of effort, competition or other form of merit.  These details are important for helping to ensure that the funding used for the programs are used as intended, but they don't change the essence of what the program is about.  It is about collecting or taking resources from one group to help another.

Generally speaking, Democrats are in favor of very large government economic assistance programs.  Also generally speaking Republicans oppose them.  Republicans are consequently often accused of being uncaring, greedy, and unwilling to help those in need, and these accusations are not always without merit.  There is, however, another side to it.

Economic assistance programs are both a good thing to do and vital to a health economy and society.  Circumstances often put people in position where they can be trapped in a cycle of failure with little or no ability to get out of that cycle and achieve success.  Sometimes this is through no fault of their own, but even when they are culpable, it is important to allow people a way out.  None of us want to live in a society where people can make a few poor decisions or simply be unlucky and have to suffer through a terrible or meager existence because of it.  Prevent that is what these programs are about.  Proving a safety net so that people can fall only so far is a good and important thing for society to do and Democrats rightly point this out and support programs to help people in this way.

On the other hand, providing assistance is not always the same as helping people. There is a danger in providing too much assistance.  Providing assistance, even when it starts out as beneficial can lead to dependence.  At a certain point, some people stop using assistance to help themselves improve and start using it to get by.  When they happens they start growing dependent on that assistance and, eventually, unable to care for themselves.  Taken to the extreme, the act of providing assistance even with the intent to help can actually cause harm.  This is  one of the issues which those of us who oppose many economic assistance programs are concerned about.

Does that seem unreasonable?  People are motivated by different things but few of us like to change.  We change only when our desire to have something different in our life overcomes the desires we've been following to that point.  Few people, for example, are good about saving money until they want to buy something they cannot afford.  People don't try to get a better job when they are happy with where they are, and the longer people go down a path the hard it is for them to change direction.

Consider someone who is out of work and starts begging to get by.  At first, the people who are giving him money are helping him.  Depending on the person and on how much money he is about to get begging, he will either use that charity to get back on his feet or he might continue begging.  As he continues it will be harder and harder for him to change from a life of begging.  Not only is it becoming more comfortable, but he is getting further removed from normal society and any work related skills or education he has are atrophying.  At some point is his begging, the money he received has changed from helping him, to hurting him.  Instead of being the thing to help get him on his feet, it has become the thing which is keeping him down.

Even when you look at less extreme circumstances.  Just as we would lose many opportunities to see great people rise up if we provided no assistance, we can also lose the opportunities to see people thrive by providing to much.  Motivation is a fine line to maintain sometimes.  Provide too little incentive for people and they will not struggle to overcome challenges.  Provide to great of challenge and they will either fail or not make the attempt.  Providing economic assistance is one significant way to manage that motivation level for people and it is something which has to be in balance.

Despite the rhetoric, it is not about helping people or not helping people.  It is about finding the right balance so that our attempts to help result in actually providing benefit and not harm as much as possible.

Friday, September 10, 2010

Why you can't increase taxes only on the rich.

It is common for politicians, when talking of raising taxes to promote the idea that they will be either taxing only the rich or taxing the rich more heavily. The idea being that they can raise the necessary revues by passing the costs only on those who can afford it.

Is that a something that any part or whole of the US government can do?  I don't think so.

Certainly, they can raise the tax rates on only those with incomes in a certain range, or they can tax only goods and or services that only the wealthy are likely to use.  But does that cost truly come from the wealthy?  Again, the answer usually is no.

The problem is that, as I say with nearly everything, it is more complicated. You cannot simply isolate one part of our economy.  When you make a change to one aspect, there are naturally changes to other parts.

Let us start with income taxes.  If you raise taxes on these high earners, what will be the result?

First you must look at what you have done.  What you have effectively done is increased the disparity between the business cost and the personal reward for the highest income labor.  To help that make sense, let's put some numbers in there.  Say we are talking about a $300,000 salary.(For now lets ignore other taxes, fees and benefits, since their impact is roughly the same before and after an income tax change).  With our current tax rate, the employee would pay about 33% of that income in federal income tax.  This means that it costs the company $300,000 to provide that employee with $201,000 in compensation (again excluding other taxes and benefits).  If you were to increase the tax rate to 40% it would then cost the company $335,000 to provide the same $201,000 in compensation or alternatively the company can pay the same $300,000 and the employee with now earn only $180,000.

If the latter result above is what happens, then the tax would primarily affect the rich.  Why is that considered to be even a likely outcome, much less the expected one?  If you were to suddenly have a permanent pay decrease for performing the same job, how would you react?  Would nothing change?  People who earn high incomes are able to do so, because they have skills which are in high demand, they have a willingness to work at a higher level than most, and/or they are willing and able to take a much higher level of responsibility.  If you decrease their compensation, most people are either going to move on to a place where they are better compensated or they are going to work less.  Either way, what you have actually taxed is not the wealthy employee, but the business.  It will have to either increase salaries to compensate to the taxes, or it will have to hire more people to do the additional work.  Essentially, employees pass on the much cost of their taxes on to their employers. Though we negotiate gross salaries, it is the net salaries that really concern employees.  Someone isn't going to do the same work for $7 an hour in take home pay that they will do for $9 an hour, even if the gross pay is $12 in either case. The same is true (perhaps more so) for those earning much higher wages.

Fair enough, businesses that can afford to pay people enough to be wealthy are wealth themselves, so taxing them is till taxing the rich.  Not exactly.

The problem with taxing companies is that you are simply increase their labor costs.  When a company has increased costs they can do many things, but they all boil down into one of two actions.  Either they increase the price of their product or they lower its quality.  This means that the increased costs of the company are felt, not by the employees but by their customers.

This is the same scenario you run into if you increase corporate or business taxes.  Increasing those taxes is simply increasing the cost of the goods or services that the business provides.  The reaction of the business will be to pass on that cost to the consumers.  In some cases this can force a reduction in the size of the company, which can cause layoffs.  The reason for this is probably a topic for another post, but it happens is most cases.

This leaves only investment income as a source of taxing the rich. Here again, you run largely into the same problem.  If you increase taxes on investment gains then you simply reduce the return on those investments.  This forces those seeking investment funds to offer more to get the same investment.  Just because investments are more expensive doesn't mean that investors are willing to risk their funds for a lower return.  The result of this is that starting companies are not able to retain as much revenue to use for growth and expansion as they instead have to use more to repay investors.  It also means that potentially profitable business are not able to get funding as their potential profits are not hight enough to attract investors.

None of what I have outlined above is 100%.  In reality the wealthy individuals targeted will pay some of the tax increases, but they will pay nowhere near all of them and the rest will be paid, indirectly, by the non-wealthy.  So while you can increase taxes on the rich and you can increase how much they pay, you cannot do so without a significant portion of those tax increases actually being paid by the poor and the middle class.

Monday, August 30, 2010

The Stimulus (pulled from a Facebook discussion)

This is something of a summary of my thoughts which were originally in response to a Facebook post started by Levi.   His posting linked to an article (link) discussing how President Obama's recent stimulus is having an effect, but it is perhaps a slower one than people expect.  His comment from reading the article was that turning around anything the size of the American economy would take time and that the large numbers of Americans who see the stimulus as a failure are being too impatient or perhaps not realizing that this is going to be a slow process.

In response, I argued that most of that problem is not so much with the American people as it has been with the messaging and communication of the White House and Congress on the issue.  We have been given dozens of projections which have consistently been very overly optimistic.  There have been regular communications of how things are getting better soon.  When the stimulus was passed, the projections of how bad things would be without it turned out to be better than reality, and the projects of how things would look with the stimulus looked to be wildly optimistic at best.   We are just leaving the time labeled by the administration as "Recovery Summer".  Though there have been some remarks from the President that recovery would take time, the overriding message for most of the year has been announcing that change is here and that things will be better soon.

The actual merits of the specific stimulus as well as the concept of using large scale government spending is something that my co-blogger and I very much disagree on and will certainly be a discussion in the near future here.  Regardless of the merits of the stimulus, however, the messaging from the White House has been terrible.  While I agree that we are, by and large, an impatient people, we are much more so when speed is part of the selling pitch.  I don't expect to sit down at a nice steakhouse and be served immediately, but if I were in McDonalds and had to wait for 20 minutes to get my food I would be pretty upset.  If you want to sell me on a long range plan for turning around the economy, fine, I'm wiling to listen and judge the plan on that merit, but when we emerge from the "Recovery Summer" program and there are very few positive economic indicators, can you really blame me for starting to doubt your plan?